Although only written a couple of years earlier this was quite a different world to The Railway Children It is a very simple kind of children s story The parents are got rid of not by sending the children away to school, nor by having them eaten by an escaped hippo from the zoo, but by the rather quaint expedient of having them go away on business.Living in the Kent countryside between a chalk quarry and a gravel pit view spoiler or Rochester and Maidstone as they are otherwise known hide spoiler This was a rather pleasant trip down memory lane for me, as I distinctly remember rushing home from school in order to watch the TV adaptation of this book Unfortunately though, I didn t enjoy this as much as I had anticipated.I can understand why this book is a children s classic It is different, imaginative, and really, let s be honest, who wouldn t want to casually find a sand fairy This book lacked something for me Something that I cannot quite put my finger on, but it has definitely resulted in me not relating to, nor caring about the children, plus, I m half considering not carrying on with the series. Somehow I missed reading Five Children and It when I was a child myself, so when I saw a copy at a yard sale I had to buy it It only cost 10p, and the little girl who sold it to me looked rather like an E Nesbit heroine, very serious, with huge dark eyes The plot is a variant on be careful what you wish for , one of her favourite themes Some of the episodes are excellent, and it s full of delightful asides But the construction is rather loose, and the ending is weak I think she was dissatisfied with it and rewrote it a few years later as The Enchanted Castle , to my mind her clear masterpiece So, if you re as much of an E Nesbit fan as I am, I definitely recommend reading this book If you like classic children s novels and aren t familiar with her work, skip straight to Castle You won t be disappointed. Nesbit is the great grandma of pretty nearly all the children s fantasy books we love, the first author to write really wittily for kids and without condescending to them, and the originator of the basic structure that carries on through C.S Lewis and Edward Eager and even in a way Jo Rowling four children, usually siblings or cousins but sometimes friends, stumble on a magical something that leads them into a series of fantastic adventures and important discoveries gently conveyed about the big issues of life Her books have a lovely period feel, not unlike the opening pages of Alice in Wonderland, tempered by Nesbit s practical sensibility about the real world and her sardonic sense of humor, which makes the books a very enjoyable read for adults as well as great read alouds.In this story, written in 1902, the magical something is a Psammead, a grumpy Persian sand fairy that looks something like a large tubby rodent with eyes on the end of stalks The Psammead is compelled to grant its finders one wish per day, which the children are initially thrilled about, but they soon discover that wishes are chancy things and the Psammead perversely literal in granting them, with often unlooked for and unideal consequences There are two sequels, THE PHOENIX AND THE CARPET, written in 1904 and my personal favorite I always hear John Gielgud s voice coming out of the Phoenix and THE STORY OF THE AMULET 1906 Theatre folks may be interested to know that Nesbit was Noel Coward s favorite writer there was a copy of THE ENCHANTED CASTLE on his bedside table at Firefly when he died Her books, he wrote, have meant a very great deal to me, not only when I was a little boy of nine and onwards, but right up to the present day I have re read them each at least twenty times.She had an economy of phrase, and an unequalled talent for evoking hot summer days in the English countryside His favorites FIVE CHILDREN AND IT, THE PHOENIX AND THE CARPET, THE HOUSE OF ARDEN, THE ENCHANTED CASTLE, THE WONDERFUL GARDEN, and the Bastable series.The Brits did a film adaptation in 2004, somewhat different to the book in the way the story gets launched, with Freddie High leading the juvenile cast, and Tara Fitzgerald, Alex Jennings, Zoe Wanamaker and Kenneth Branagh as the adults In a stroke of total casting genius, the voice of the Psammead is provided by Eddie Izzard. For some reason when I was a kid and I first read this book, it terrified the hell out of me I don t remember why I think back when I was growing up in PMQ housing there had been shadows on the wall from the asbestos removal junk the military had set up in the attic above my bed, shadows which I thought were It I know, incredibly lame in hindsight My eight year old mind was also mixing up It with Cousin It, the creepy hairy guy from The Addams Family 1990 s films Going back and reading this classic tale as an adult is a whole different experience, and the book has a great mix of nostalgia and innocence to make it memorable It s an endearing story if not a bit preachy, but less unsettling than Peter Pan and other similar stories from its time I definitely enjoyed the book than the film the film adaptation is hokey and goofy and doesn t really capture the true spirit of the book in the same way, nor are the characters as well developed as in the book It s a bit dated but still a welcome classic on my bookshelf. Ladies and gentlemen 3,5 I will try something, which until now had never done to write three reviews in one day Unfortunately I could not get to write three reviews on the same day, because I was helping my boss with the proceedings, and do not regret me pass it to me as a child I liked this book, being Edith Nesbit was to be expected, and as I said I was thinking about putting 4 stars, but there have been several factors, which have prevented me from it In the first place is that I think the best will be required, and certainly Edith Nesbit has talent, for much This story I liked a lot, but not as much as treasure hunters fromsearch true or their tales of dragons Firstly, I believe that it should explain the reason why I read this book Months ago in April, I read that book of the history of fantasy fromsearch true written by Silvia Pato , and edited by Nowtilus publishing, despite his anti Christian bias, and feminist is a book that I liked, and I recommend, despite their unfairest prejudice In that book spoke of Edith Nesbit I already knew the five guys, and that in part because Goodreads, recommended it to me and my conversations with the Professor Manuel Alfonseca I discovered thanks to the brief history of the fantasy to five guys and that was based on a Japanese anime, which I saw in the tve1 when small Shamed was the magic Elf, which I loved elduendemagico However, it seems to be that there were differences, which we will be examining.First thing, I must say this book It is that I really enjoyed the Edition, which has made the editorial El Paseo I must say, that I will continue to this editorial with enormous interest It was a success by the editorial El Paseo rescue the original drawings.The beginning, perhaps a little weaker than expected, but very well are the following chapters, which are among the best that has been written in children s literature, if Edith Nesbit had maintained that pace during the entire novel, no doubt you would have put the five stars to the book Those pages reminded me of the best moments of golden age Kenneth Grahame and the William of Richmal Crompton the William, will always be a kid s version of the great P.G Wodehouse that sometimes even manages to overcome it , but going back to five children and that one of the biggest attractions of the book is without a doubt the moral and ethical tone of the book Aside from that the five children in this case three children one a baby and two girls live incredible adventures We will see how Nesbit encouraged against greed remember, that these stories Edith Nesbit wrote them for his son, as did Kenneth Grahame, James Mathew Barrie for prot g s, James A.A Milne or the own J.R.R Tolkien Sometimes we will be touched considerably At least in some chapter I felt deeply moved Also despite being a novel halfway between realism and fantasy all in one of the stories, because except, that sometime the wishes are lengthened into two chapters, but usually every wish is a chapter With all Nesbit in one of wishes you will use a resource, which will be then used in many novels of fantasy, science fiction uy I do not say that, should the users of Goodreads, who read this book find out for itself One of the positive things about this wonderful book is the number of writers who quote and Nesbit refers to them as to Rudyard Kipling or the own Anstey, the author of vice versa a lesson for parents in fact the author herself in the final chapter tells us, F Anstey book inspired her to end The brass bottle In this story a genius ask which desires does not perform them well, and up to the end just getting his master in the bottle, and replacing him, getting rid of the problem by, someone asked him, wish this had not happened Nesbit also speaks a story of medieval adventures of Ralph de Courcy, but I have not managed to find With all the Knight Sir Wulfric de Talbot left me a great mark Now we are going to talk about the crux issue why they have not given him four stars We all know that Psamead, or that is a fairy of sand, which is leading in the hole since prehistoric times, I think, to tell the story to his son Nesbit was very strict with the chronology, by what we will see many anachronisms I doubt that the primitive men asked him to Psamead Ictiosaurios, and other types of lizards Nor does it seem very credible, that the Psamead tell the story of the son of the Assyrian king, when it was buried in prehistory How did it know if it was buried Another thing is that the Psamead says, that wishes only last a day, but has the power, so the maid Martha does not know and that lasts forever , and also manage to make the Psamead to grant them the desire before ordering it How it is possible that you have so much power, for one thing, and then so little for other Another thing that infuriates me is that children in particular to Anthea Panther You ll want to, but the Psamead is somewhat obnoxious, and since then I do not know the reader, but certainly I do not fell I well It is the sullen and surly with what I found I also wonder if Robert has no part of reason to say, if the Psamead is an evil fairy What says you Father Brown Flambeau in Sins of the Saradine Prince when he said that they wrote fairytale know than that you, or when he says that he didn t say that it was wrong to enter into the Kingdom of fairies, but always had danger in it That s the pay, none of the wishes granted to boys goes well This is the difference that I have with Nesbit Why is so generous to the boys of The treasure seekers and instead is hard with these poor guys In my opinion we learn hard lessons of life If the Psamead as they appreciate not want to, or not it can grant wishes, should have said from the beginning, although of course, but there would be no novel Yet I suspect, that Nesbit was Socialist Fabiana with all the story we must recognize, that makes no apology for socialism, or tries to inoculate the reader Only lightly in The railway children is also a good novel I think, it kind of Treasure hunters , because they are poor, and instead of these not is it mercy, because they need to go We talked about my friend Alfonseca, and I of this circumstance, and said that left wing writers such as Aldous Huxley, and Arthur C Clarke always felt preference for Buddhism I believe that Nesbit is something good, that I learn to be happy with what we have, but, although the Psamead says, that they are not asking well wishes My impression is that you except the final wishes I think Nesbit is wrong in one thing and it s not bad to want things, provided that what is asked is good I think about my favorite series Doraemon The Gadget Cat from the future Inventions are not bad, but the way that Nobita, Suneo and Giant employ them I told a joke to my friend Alfonseca and said no I wanted you, because we ll do it for you My friend told me, that one of the stories, that delves into the subject of how dangerous that is ask certain desires is the story of the hand of the monkey Not a big fan of the Simpsons I am lately, but don t miss out on the fun Halloween, that made this story of W.W Jacobs I believe that the screenwriter had even worse bad grapes, that own Jacobs The same thing happens, I think with the desires The last wishes are a both absurd, and are not as good as the middle Although there is one very funny that Nesbit get call and call to the Hilary Maur W baby lamb three ways and the uses of comic and hilarious way with much wit In short, it is a very good book, but a little bit, has lacked to overcome that line that separates the good from the great All in all, a very entertaining reading..Damas y caballeros voy a intentar algo, que hasta el momento nunca hab a hecho escribir tres cr ticas en un d a Desgraciadamente no pude conseguir escribir tres cr ticas el mismo d a, porque estuve ayudando a mi Jefe con las Actas, y no me arrepiento me lo pase como un ni o Este libro me ha gustado mucho mi nota es de 3,5 siendo Edith Nesbit era de esperar, y como dije estuve pensando ponerle 4 estrellas, pero ha habido varios factores, que me lo han impedido En primer lugar es que yo pienso que a los mejores hay que exigirles, y ciertamente Edith Nesbit tiene talento, para mucho m s Esta historia me ha gustado much simo, pero no tanto como Buscadores de tesoros o sus cuentos de dragones En primer lugar, creo, que deber a explicar el motivo por el que le este libro Hace meses en abril, le ese libro de la Historia de la fantas a escrito por Silvia Pato , y editado por la editorial Nowtilus, pese a su sesgo anticristiano, y feminista es un libro que me gust mucho, y que, recomiendo, pese a sus injust simos prejuicios En ese libro se hablaba de Edith Nesbit yo, ya conoc a los Cinco chicos, y eso en parte porque me lo recomend Goodreads, y por mis conversaciones con el Profesor Manuel Alfonseca Descubr gracias a La breve historia de la fantas a que Cinco chicos y eso estaba basado en un anime japon s, que yo ve a en la tve1 cuando era peque o Shamed el Duende m gico, que me encantaba Con todo, parece ser, que hab a diferencias, que iremos examinando.Lo primero, que debo decir de este libro Es que me ha gustado mucho la edici n, que ha hecho la editorial El Paseo Debo decir, que seguir a esta editorial con enorme inter s Fue un acierto por parte de la editorial El Paseo rescatar los dibujos originales.El comienzo, quiz sea un poco m s flojo de lo esperado, pero est n muy bien los siguientes cap tulos, que est n entre lo mejor, que se ha escrito en literatura infantil, si Edith Nesbit hubiera mantenido ese ritmo durante toda la novela, sin duda le habr a puesto las cinco estrellas al libro Esas p ginas me recordaron a los mejores momentos de La edad dorada de Kenneth Grahame y los Guillermos de Richmal Crompton Los Guillermos, siempre ser n una versi n infantil del gran P.G Wodehouse que a veces incluso llega a superarlo , pero volviendo a Cinco ni os y eso uno de los mayores atractivos del libro es sin duda el tono moral, y tico del libro Al margen de que los cinco ni os en este caso tres ni os uno un bebe y dos chicas vivan unas aventuras incre bles Veremos c mo Nesbit les alienta contrala codicia cabe recordar, que estos cuentos Edith Nesbit los escrib a para su hijo, como lo hicieron Kenneth Grahame, James Mathew Barrie para sus protegidos, James A.A Milne o el propio J.R.R Tolkien Algunos momentos nos enternecer n considerablemente Yo por lo menos en alg n cap tulo me sent hondamente conmovido Tambi n pese a ser una novela a medio camino entre el realismo y la fantas a con todo en una de las historias, porque salvo, que en alg n momento los deseos se alargan en dos cap tulos, pero generalmente cada deseo es un cap tulo Con todo Nesbit en uno de los deseos usar un recurso, que luego ser utilizada en muchas novelas de fantas a, uy ciencia ficci n No digo cual eso, deber n los usuarios de Goodreads, que lean este libro descubrirlo por s mismo Otra de las cosas positivas de este maravilloso libro es la cantidad de escritores a los que cita y a los que Nesbit hace referencia como a Rudyard Kipling o el propio Anstey el autor de Viceversa una lecci n para padres de hecho la propia autora en el cap tulo final nos dice, que libro de F Anstey la inspir , para el final The brass bottle En este relato un genio al que le piden deseos no los realiza bien, y encima al final acaba metiendo a su amo en la botella, y sustituy ndole, libr ndose del problema haciendo, que alguien le pidiese, desear a que esto no hubiera ocurrido Tambi n Nesbit habla de un relato de aventuras medievales de Ralph de Courcy, pero no lo he conseguido encontrar Con todo me dej una gran impronta el caballero Sir Wulfric de Talbot.Ahora vamos a hablar del quid de la cuesti n de Por qu no le he dado las cuatro estrellas Todos sabemos que Psamead, o el Eso es un hada de arena, que se supone, que lleva en el agujero desde la prehistoria, yo creo, que al contarle el relato a su hijo Nesbit no fue muy rigurosa con la cronolog a, por lo que veremos muchos anacronismos Dudo que los hombres primitivos le pidieran al Psamead Ictiosaurios, y otros tipos de saurios Tampoco me parece muy cre ble, que el Psamead cuente la historia del hijo del Rey Asirio, cuando se enterr en la prehistoria C mo lo supo si estaba enterrado Otra cosa es que el Psamead dice, que los deseos s lo duran un d a, pero tiene el poder, para que la criada Martha no se entera y eso dura para siempre , y tambi n se las arreglan para que el Psamead les conceda el deseo antes de pedirlo C mo es posible que tenga tanto poder, para una cosa, y luego tan poco para otras Otra cosa, que me enfurece es que a los ni os en especial a Anthea la pantera le gustar , pero el Psamead es un tanto odioso, y desde luego no s al lector, pero desde luego a m no me cay bien Es lo m s hura o, y arisco con lo que me he encontrado Adem s yo me pregunto si Robert no tiene parte de raz n al decir, si el Psamead es un hada mal fica Lo que le apunta el Padre Brown a Flambeau en Los pecados del Pr ncipe Saradine cuando dec a que los que escrib an de cuentos de hadas sab an m s de eso que usted, o cuando dice que no dijo que fuera malo entrar en el reino de las hadas, sino que siempre hab a peligro en ello Esa es la paga, que ninguno de los deseos concedidos a los chicos sale bien Esta es la diferencia, que yo tengo con Nesbit Por qu es tan generosa con los chicos de Los buscadores de tesoros y en cambio es tan dura con estos pobres chicos En mi opini n les hace aprender de forma muy dura las lecciones de la vida Si el Psamead como se apreciar no quiere, o no puede conceder deseos, deber a haberlo dicho desde el principio, aunque claro, sino no habr a novela Con todo yo sospecho, que Nesbit que era socialista Fabiana con todo el relato hay que reconocer, que no hace apolog a del socialismo, ni trata de inocularlo al lector S lo ligeramente en Los chicos del ferrocarril que tambi n es una buena novela Yo, creo, que se apiada de los Buscadores de tesoros , porque son pobres, y en cambio de estos no se apiada tanto, porque pasan necesidad Estuvimos hablando mi amigo Alfonseca, y yo de esta circunstancia, y me dijo que escritores de izquierdas como Aldous Huxley, y Arthur C Clarke siempre sintieron preferencias por el budismo Yo, creo, que Nesbit trata algo bueno, de que aprendamos a ser felices con lo que tenemos, pero, aunque el Psamead dice, que no est n pidiendo bien los deseos Mi impresi n es que salvo los deseos finales Yo, creo, que Nesbit se equivoca en una cosa y es que no es malo desear cosas, siempre que lo que se pide sea bueno Pienso en mi serie favorita Doraemon The Gadget Cat from the future Los inventos no son malos, sino la forma en que los emplean Nobita, Suneo, y Gigante Yo le cont un chiste a mi amigo Alfonseca y le dije no dese usted, ya lo haremos nosotros por usted Mi amigo me dijo, que uno de los relatos, que ahonda m s en el tema de lo peligroso que es pedir ciertos deseos es el relato de la Mano del mono No soy ltimamente un gran fan de los Simpsons, pero no se pierdan el divertido Halloween, que hicieron de ese relato de W.W Jacobs Yo creo, que el guionista a n ten a peor mala uva, que el propio Jacobs.Lo mismo pasa creo, yo con los deseos Los ltimos deseos son un tanto absurdos, y no son tan buenos como los del medio Aunque hay uno muy divertido en el que Nesbit consigue denominar y llamar al bebe corderito de tres maneras diferentes Hilary Maur W y la emplea de forma c mica, e hilarante con mucho ingenio.En resumen, es un libro muy bueno, pero le ha faltado un poquit n, para superar esa l nea que separa lo bueno de lo grandioso Con todo, una lectura muy entretenida. Five Children And It Is A Cult Classic That Has Never Been Out Of Print Since Its Publication In E Nesbit Mixes Realism And Fantasy In One Of Children S Literature S Most Enduring Fables Be Careful What You Wish For When Five Children Robert, Anthea, Cyril, Jane And Baby Lamb Move From London To Rural Kent, They Are Amazed To Find An Ancient Sand Fairy While Playing In A Gravel Pit This Psammead Has The Power To Grant Wishes, But The Children Will Soon Discover That Wishing Is A Dangerous Business And The Consequences May Not Always Be To Their Liking I loved this book as a child, and read it over and over The idea of having a wish every day is so appealing, but then seeing how it goes hilariously wrong day after day is great, too I read this aloud to my kids July 2015 , and though my 10yo liked it, my 6yo was less engaged I found myself having to stop and explain things here and there, because it s both old fashioned and British I think it s easier to read to yourself, you can SEE how the name Anthea becomes Panther becomes Panty in baby talk, but when someone reads to you that Anthea says, Come to own Panty to the baby, it just sounds weird.Still, a fun book, at least in my opinion This is a perfectly delightful story of the misadventures of five siblings who are granted a daily wish by a prehistoric creature who lives in the sandpit near their home One of the eleven chapters would, by modern standards, be deemed racist However, this fault might be overlooked when the reader considers the date of publication and could be used as a teachable moment if reading with a child All in all, this entertaining tale elicited many chuckles and the occasional loud guffaw The most fun I ve had since reading The Red Blazer Girls books earlier this year. Five children practically left on this own in a English countryside This book was published in 1902, almost 50 years before C S Lewis wrote his The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe.However, the similarity ends there The story of Five Children and It does not bring you to a magical world at the back of a wardrobe Rather, what the five children, Robert, Anthea, Cyril, Jane, and their baby brother, the Lamb find is a Psammead or a sand fairy has gotten buried in the sand since the Stone Age The five children are digging the sand thinking that they will be able to see the other side of the earth particularly the Australian children Funny, but this thought also came in my mind as a small boy when I learned in school that the earth is round and so I dug and dug in our backyard using a small gardening bolo I wished to see the other side of the world but I was afraid that the earth would collapse if I succeed 2004 film adaptation directed by John Stephenson Be careful what you wish for is the main lesson that children can derive from this book The reason for this is that Psammead has the ability to grant children s wishes However, during the stone age, most wishes were about food so the bones turned to stones fossilized Now, things are different because the five children s wishes are not food or food related and for each wish they learn a lesson because of the consequences resulting from it So, the finding of the Psammead and its ability to grant wishes become like a big frame story and each wish becomes a small independent story The ending feels like an afterthought, thus, weak It is like E Nesbit felt like the book was becoming too long for comfort.It s just an okay book for me Nothing really extraordinary.
Edith Nesbit married name Edith Bland 15 August 1858 4 May 1924 was an English author and poet she published her books for children under the name of E Nesbit.She wrote or collaborated on over 60 books of fiction for children, several of which have been adapted for film and television She was also a political activist and co founded the Fabian Society, a socialist organisation later connec
- 256 pages
- Five Children and It
- E. Nesbit
- 20 July 2017 E. Nesbit